Southwest Research and Outreach Center

University of Minnesota Extension Service Flexible Crop Cash Rents

By: Erlin Weness , University of Minnesota Extension Educator in Farm Management
September 2001

Print this page using Acrobat Reader

 
Cash rental rates for crops are typically agree to in advance and paid on a fixed amount per acre. Typical cash rents range from $60 to $150 per acre in southern Minnesota. A fixed cash rent locks in the rent to be paid irrespective of the yield of grain or price received. The tenant may get large or very poor production and a good or poor price for the crop, yet he/she is obligated to pay the agree rental rate. The tenant in cash rent arrangement assumes all price and yield risk.  

A flexible cash rental arrangement can be put in place that seeks to share the risk between the owner and the tenant. Many types of flexible cash rental arrangements can be established beyond those discussed here. Listed below are several common flexible cash rent alternatives.

 

1) Based on a set bushel amount

A rental agreement could be established in which the tenant agrees to pay the landowner the value of a set bushel per acre. Example: The agreement might be for the tenant to pay the value of 50 bushel of corn per acre and 15 bushel of soybeans at the price determined at the local elevator at noon on December 1. If the price were $2.00 for corn and $5.00 for soybeans, the rents would be $100 (50 x $2.00) on the corn acres and $75 (15 x $5.00) on the soybean acres. 

2) Based on a percentage of the crop

This would be similar to #1 except that instead of a set bushel per acre, the agreed amount would be 30 to 40% of the crop. Example: The agreement could call for a cash payment based on 40% of the crop with a price determined from a fall forward price bid cash contract at the local elevator on May 1 of the crop year. Assume the corn yield was 150 bushel and the soybean yield was 50 bushel and the forward contract bid on May 1 was $1.75 for corn and $5.00 for soybeans. The rents would be $105.00 (150 bu. x 40% x $1.75) on the corn acres and $100 (50 bu. x 40% x $5.00) on the soybean acres.

3) Adjust the rent for price only

This approach would transfer some of the price risk to the owner, but the tenant would retain all the yield risk. This method requires that you establish a base rent and an average price. If the price varied from the predetermined price, the rent would be adjusted up or down. Example: The agreed base rent is $80.00 per acre and the agreed price is $2.00 per bushel on corn.  If the actual price as determined at a particular time and place is $2.50, the $80.00 rent would be adjusted by a formula of $2.50/$2.00 or 125%. The rent would be $100 ($80.00 x $2.50/$2.00 = $100). A similar formula would be set up for all crops.

4) Adjust rents for yield only 

This approach transfers some of the yield risk to the owner, but leaves the tenant with the price risk. This approach might be particularly useful in the present day where it is difficult to determine a true price since total returns are impacted by governmental loan deficiency payments, loan rates, marketing gains and price disaster payments. This method requires establishing a base rent and a base yield and adjusting the payment by the actual yield. Example: Assume a base yield is established at 47 bushel of soybeans with a $100 base rent, if the actual yield is 42 bushels or 52 bushels per acre the rent would be adjusted accordingly. The rent would be 42/47 or 89.36 percent of $100 or $89.36 per acre if the yield were 42 bushel per acre. It would be 52/47 or 110.63% of $100 or $110.63 if the soybeans yielded 52 bushel per acre. A similar formula would be set up for all other crops on the farm.

5) Adjusting rents for price and yield

This approach allocates price and yield risk between landowner and tenant. It is perhaps the most comprehensive approach discussed.   A base rent is established that is later adjusted for price and yield. Example: If the agreed base rent is $100, base yield for corn is 150 bushel, and price is $2.00 per bushel, the following calculations would be made to determine the actual rent paid. Use the actual price and yield as the numerator of the fraction and the agreed price and yield as the denominator of the fraction multiplied by the base rent to determine the rent. If the actual yield was 160 bushel and the actual price was $1.90, the formula would calculate the rents of $101.33 ($100 x 160/150 x $1.90/$2.00= $100 x 106.66% x 95% = $101.33).

Typically 50% of cropland rents are paid in the spring and 50% in the fall. This practice could continue with ˝ of the base rent paid in the spring and the remaining adjusted amount paid in the fall.

A minimum and a maximum rental rate could be established on any type of flexible cash rent. It could be agreed that in no case would the rent paid be less than $75 nor more than $125 per acre.

Tenant and landowner should negotiate realistic terms that fit the property and finances of both parties. Before agreeing to any flexible arrangement, figure various scenarios of price and yield to determine if you can live with the agreement if prices or yields are high or low. Particular attention should be given as to how and when prices will be determined. Will you use a straight cash price on a given day at a specific elevator or will you use the average of several dates or use futures prices adjusted by basis or forward contract bids to determine a fair price? If yield is a factor in your flexible rental arrangement, how will it be determined, by over the scale measurement, yield monitor or bin estimation?

Once the tenant and landowner agree on a flexible cash rent plan, the next step is to put it in writing. Lay out the terms and conditions on paper and both sign it. Both should retain copies.

Examples:

Here are further examples of how the five types of variable cash rent formulas would be calculated for soybeans. Example: The agreed upon base yield is 40 bushels/acre, the base price is $5.00 per bushel and the base rent is $90.00 per acre. Actual yields were 50 bushel and the price was $4.50 per bushel.

1) Based on a set bushel (15)

       

Crop

Set Bushel

 

Price

Adjusted Cash Rent

Soybeans

15 bu

x

$5.00

$75

 

________

______

x

_____

_______

 

________

______

x

_____

_______

 
           

2) Based on a percentage of the crop (33%)

Crop

Percentage

 

Yield

Price

Adjusted Cash Rent

Soybeans

33%

x

50 bu.

$5.00

$82.50

________

______

x

_____

_______              x

_______

________

______

x

_____

_______              x

_______

           

3) Adjusted for price only

Crop

Base Rent

x

Actual Price

Actual Yield

Adjusted Cash Rent

     

Expected Price

Expected Yield

 

Soybeans

$90.00

x

$4.50/$5.00

 

$81.00

_________

______

 

______/______

 

__________

_________

______

 

______/______

 

__________

           

4) Adjusted for yield only

Soybeans

$90.00

x

 

50bu. / 40 bu.

$112.5

_________

______

x

 

_____/_______

__________

_________

______

x

 

_____/_______

__________

           

5) Adjust for price and yield

Soybeans

$90.00

x

$4.50/$5.00

50bu. / 40 bu.

$101.25

_________

______

x

______/______

_____/_______

__________

_________

______

x

______/______

_____/_______

__________


Return to the Farm Management Page
Return to the SWROC Home Page


This page was created on 9/28/01 by Erlin Weness with assistance from M. Werner.